So, I spent a couple of days doing “small” things and finishing up on stuff I’d already started, but it didn’t seem like anything worth writing a whole post about. Then we hit today, and I did such a big thing that it seems like it deserves its own. So, I’ll try to update about things like the new car estimate (totally different from the first) and giving myself permission to throw away a whole bunch of baby socks later on, but not right now. Instead, I’m starting with what’s been going on around here today and why it’s such a big deal.
Here’s Where We Are
Most of you know that I have two little ones. They are both very bright girls and wonderful little people. But, I will admit that I have been struggling with my older girl for a while. Between her behavior and the fact that Lucy has decided to do the X-TREME version of toddlerhood (her entire life could be narrated by one of those guys who does the monster truck commercials), Rob and I are considering creating our own support group and naming it Pa.T.T. (Parents of Tiny Terrorists). Some days I really do feel like I’m just being held hostage by some miniature rebel army that survives on rations of peanut butter and honey sandwiches and Goldfish crackers.
Dot is just a bit over four now, and her behavior has been pretty intense for some time. I really do chalk a fair amount of it up to how smart she is. The child has an amazing vocabulary and can string together cause and effect like nobody’s business.
Unfortunately, developmental milestones being what they are, just because she has a certain level of knowledge doesn’t mean she has the emotional capacity to utilize it appropriately. Or, in more direct terms:
My child uses her powers for evil.
Yes, that sounds really harsh, and I mean it mostly in jest. Besides, I’ll probably say worse things before we get to the end of this post. The thing is, my kiddo is a typical four-year-old when it comes to things like desire and impulse control. Where she’s not so typical, however, is in the lengths she will go to in order to manipulate a situation to get what she wants.
The Bad and the Ugly (Sometimes It Doesn’t Feel Like There’s a Whole Lot of “Good”)
There’s so very much to be said about this whole situation, and I fear that if I get rolling too much I’ll either end up writing a dissertation on why you should never have children, or I’ll come across as sounding far too defensive…and I don’t think either of those things would be all that accurate. Simply put, things have been pretty hard. She was talking back, waking up in a nasty mood, screaming when she didn’t get her way, lashing out at her little sister, and generally poking the Mama Bear with a great big stick to get a reaction.
I was beside myself. I had been trying to do everything right. We were “catching” her doing good things and praising them, I was creating challenges for her to rise up and meet, I was trying to provide one-on-one attention. It seemed to be no use. So much of what I had read indicated that she was trying to get attention, and everyone says that if kids don’t get the positive attention they crave, they’ll seek negative attention.
This was just one of the many reasons that I started wondering if all the parenting books I was reading happened to be missing the same chapter. They all give the same advice, but they all stop in the same place, too. In this case, the books all advised that Dot wasn’t getting enough positive attention. But, how could that be? Sure, I am distracted at times and don’t allow myself to be at my child’s beck and call, but she certainly wasn’t suffering from a lack of positive interaction or reinforcement. One of the things that would reduce me to tears was how she would literally stop us in the midst of a positive activity to do something simply because it was “naughty.” If her behavior was all about seeking attention, why would she stop me from giving her positive attention in order to give her negative attention?
I still don’t have an answer to this question.
OK, There Was Some Good, Now That I Think About It
I knew that her behavioral issues were something that I wanted to tackle early on with this whole Something Good project, and Darling Husband Rob and I spent some time last month preparing for it. This isn’t even our first go-round with this whole thing, and I found that some changes I made back in January seemed to yield some pretty amazing results. After a very long time of dealing with insolent behavior, disagreeable moods, and what I will admit were a whole lot of hurt feelings on my part, I saw such a change in her that instead of crying out of frustration, I now found myself fighting back tears of relief and pride. She became so much calmer and more in control of herself. She was overflowing with love for her family and showing much more interest in preschool. She would bound down the stairs in the mornings with a smile, a hug, and a cheerful “Good morning, Mama!” It was about night and day from where we’d been.
Only a Paragraph’s Worth, Apparently…
But, then the girls and I went on a cross-country trip for 2 ½ weeks, and despite starting strong, by the time we got back home, I had lost my sweet, precious girl again. It was fairly devastating. I saw that glimpse of the loving, caring toddler she had been, and although I didn’t want to get my hopes up too much, I was starting to think we had rounded the corner. When she regressed, I felt utterly defeated.
Yes, I Get That a Lot of This Is As Much About Me as It Is About Her
I suppose I should probably break in here and explain why this is such a problem. First of all, I take my job as a guardian very seriously. I am not just the biological parent of this child, but I am the person (along with my husband, of course) who is charged with guiding her through her experiences so that she can learn what she needs to in order to become a “good” adult. The concepts of compassion and empathy are very important ones to me, and I feel that it is a parent’s duty to help develop these in their children. When I see a lack of these things in my own child’s behavior, it worries me terribly.
Worrying is another big part of my job, it seems. I worry about them falling down the stairs. I worry about the girls not getting enough Vitamin D. And I worry a considerable amount about the kind of people they are now and will be in the future.
Another huge reason that this behavior is a problem for me personally, is because it has brought out an ugly side in myself. Even if I could be considered a little high-strung from time to time, I’m typically a pretty laid-back person. I’m a fan of the live-and-let-live philosophy. I don’t believe in violence and get incredibly uncomfortable when there’s any kind of conflict.
So, it’s been a huge surprise to discover that I am now a yeller. I’ve never been one to raise my voice in anything but good cheer, and now I find myself in the middle of blood-boiling rages, yelling at these tiny people who seem to be willfully driving me toward the edge of a cliff at impossible speeds.
And I feel awful about it. This is not the person I want to be and certainly not how I view myself. But it’s sort of indisputable that I’ve become a yeller. It honestly feels like there is no other way to be heard around here, and when I’ve asked you nicely several times to stop sticking your feet in my face and you continue to do it while laughing at the fact that it makes me angry, there’s a good chance I’m going to break. It’s just awful.
I’ve Been Looking for Answers
So, I turned to friends who often had the caring, but not immediately-helpful advice that things will get better. Then I turned to parenting books, and they all seemed to stop just short of being useful. I’ve read everything from Parenting with Love and Logic, to Have a New Kid by Friday (just to show you an example of the extremes on both ends). Really, most of these books are offering pretty similar advice. OK, if I’m being honest, most of them take about the first 1/3 to ½ of the book trying to convince you why you need the book, which is incredibly annoying. You don’t need to sell me the book; I’ve already paid for it. I just want some HELP!
Anyway, most of the books tell you what I’ve mentioned before about positive and negative attention. They then offer a variety of options on redirecting, distracting, punishing, etc. And then, you’re on your own. One of the most common things they tell you is “ignore the behavior and it will go away.” Really? That sounds awesome!!!
Except, what do you do when ignoring the behavior actually turns into having someone stomp around behind you from room to room doing the same exact behavior, only now she’s doing it at ear-piercing levels while sobbing and probably attempting to hang off of some part of your body? None of the books covered that.
Well, one kind of did, which is why we are where we are now. Rob and I, completely independently, both found our way to a book called The Brat Stops Here. Again, I’m sure it’s appalling to someone right now that I would even consider looking at a book that insinuated my child was a brat…but those people don’t live in my house. Early on in the book, it describes several different kinds of brats…and my kid fell into all but one category. I saw this as kind of validating, because I was pretty sure we were at Defcon 2, and it was nice to have a little confirmation that maybe things were as bad as I feared. (Don’t get me wrong, it would have also been pretty cool to discover that my kid was really a whole lot better than most and I was just overreacting and needed to get a grip on reality.)
Last month, Rob read the book. Then I read the book. We agreed that there were some principles in there that we could get behind and would be willing to try. I read the book again and took 13 pages of notes. Then, we used our date night to go out to dinner and talk about the 13 pages of notes and to take more notes on what we talked about. I made secret phone calls to get other people in cahoots with our plans and we filled in charts and put asterisks by important line items and so on and so forth.
Despite keeping things pretty well under wraps, Dot must have sensed some sort of disturbance in the Force, because all of a sudden, her behavior took a turn for the better. She had eight days with something like one timeout. She said things like “Oh, good!” when you told her she had school in the morning. We rarely heard the word “poop.” I started to falter just a bit. Maybe we didn’t need our new plan after all. Maybe the ship was finally righting itself all on its own…
Instead, we decided to look at it as a great starting place. We kept our determination that this was the right path and decided that we would implement the new system on a weekend. I know full-well that ignoring behaviors that are designed specifically to provoke me will be very difficult. We’re also aware that kids tend to push really hard against an uncomfortable change, so it seemed wise to have us both home for a couple of days at the beginning of this whole thing to sort of tag-team if necessary. If one of us starts to get worn down, the other can take over.
And Here We Are at Day One
We introduced our new plan to Dot this morning at breakfast. Over the last weeks we revamped how we do timeout, so that’s helped with the transition, I think. We laid out some clear ideas of what is and isn’t acceptable. We didn’t create rules for every aspect of life, rather we chose a few key behaviors that we want to extinguish and are focusing on them. We made her aware of what she can expect, rather than just dumping a whole new system on an unsuspecting four-year-old.
The funny thing is, now that we’ve put all this planning into it, what we’re doing doesn’t seem like all that big of a deal. In fact, it’s kind of right in line with what the books were recommending, but with some tweaks for our own personal beliefs. I think it also helps tremendously that I’ve just taken the time to mentally prepare for the worst case scenario, and to realize that things will probably go much more smoothly than I feared when we first started kicking these ideas around a month ago. Like I said above, I’m aware that a lot of this is as much about me as it is about the kid.
I imagine I’ll get more into detail about what we’ve changed as the month goes on and we evaluate our progress. The biggest things really are that we’ve created a few tools for her to use to calm herself when needed, we’ve made timeout much more isolated, and we’re steadfastly ignoring non-dangerous behaviors that are used merely to manipulate us into getting angry.
We’re about 12 hours in, and so far, so good. Wish us luck, and I will add in updates as we go along regarding Dot’s responses, as well as my own reflections on how it feels from my standpoint. I can say that we’ve had two instances of her yelling and yelling when we ignored her behavior, and I found that two things happened:
1. I didn’t lose my temper.
2. They didn’t last all that long.
I’d call that pretty successful so far!